In this awkwardly revealing Thanksgiving episode, Mariann dives into the meat industry’s internal civil war as beef enthusiasts attempt a coup against Big Turkey just in time for the holidays. We witness the spectacle of industry professionals clutching their pearls when faced with market competition while simultaneously patting themselves on the back for their “noble sacrifice” of industrial animal slaughter. Meanwhile, dairy producers reluctantly acknowledge that maybe, just possibly, cows might prefer stable social groups and not having their babies taken away – who knew animal welfare might actually matter?
- Turkey vs. Beef Showdown: Meat industry infighting erupts as beef advocate Gregory Bloom suggests replacing Thanksgiving turkey, triggering defensive backlash from turkey farmers.
- Trump’s Beef Backlash: Cattle ranchers turn on Trump over Argentine beef imports and meatpacker investigations, exposing hypocrisy in their free market rhetoric.
- Dairy’s Welfare Admission: Journal of Dairy Science acknowledges cows need stable social groups and natural behaviors, signaling growing consumer pressure on animal welfare issues.
- Support Our Hen House: Triple your impact with matched donations at ourhenhouse.org/support during year-end fundraising campaign.
INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT
Mariann Sullivan: Welcome to Rising Anxieties. This is the time of the week, every week we do this, start off the day by unpacking what's worrying the meat industry. Isn't, isn't that normal behavior? And also what's worrying us about the meat industry and about a few other things. And, uh, well, I, I'm a worrier, what can I say?
Uh, before I start the worry, uh, don't forget, we're a podcast and we're on YouTube, so you can listen to this anywhere, uh, that you listen to podcasts or you can watch it on YouTube. Please remember to subscribe and hit like wherever you listen. I mean, assuming you do like it, uh, even if you don't, uh, 'cause it really helps us.
Alright. We're talking about Thanksgiving this week as, as, as is appropriate. And, uh, there's nothing I love more than when segments of the meat industry fight each other. And that's what's going on on meatingplace.com, one of the, the industry sites that we follow all the time. Alright, this is by this guy Gregory Bloom, and he starts off by saying, Cancel the Turkey. Keep the holiday.
He's all about, he's all about, uh, red meat. So, and he thinks it's high time we ditched the whole bird turkey tradition and opted for something smarter, tastier, and far easier on the supply chain. I could not agree with that more. Unfortunately, the alternatives he's proposing, of course, are not what I would propose.
He starts off by saying that the Turkey industry is in trouble. Uh, uh, you know, obviously bird flu is, is big problem, and, and he thinks it's a really big problem that, that they have to gear up every year for this huge, huge supply and then wait 51 weeks for the next sprint. And, uh, processors are increasingly steering capacity toward boning out parts, sounds like fun, deli meats and value added items like ground turkey instead of whole birds.
Uh, because parts deliver better margins, more consistent demand, and far less seasonal whiplash. I wonder if there's anything... all right, this isn't me just being really optimistic, but if there's anything about the whole bird that puts people off at all? They like it to be in parts, don't they?
I think that was one of the first foods that I noticed that, Ew. Oh, this appears to be an animal. Took me a while to figure it out. You know, not the brightest bulb in the chandelier. Um, alright, he made this very inefficient and costly to just gear up this huge amount for, for Thanksgiving every year. And clearly he cares a lot about the turkey industry.
Uh, no, he doesn't really, he cares about the beef industry. And, um, so he also points out that chicken is better if it's air chilled, whereas turkey has to be dunk chilled. I have no idea. All sounds disgusting. Um, and then the myth of turkey as a cheap holiday option. He points out that if you count it per pound, you're paying for all the other stuff, the, the, the bones and, and all of that. So you might be paying twice for what you think you're actually paying per pound. Uh. And, um, compared to that, he said, compare that to a standing rib roast. I say, compare it to some lentils. Uh, you know, but nobody's listening to me. Well, you are. Thank you.
Um, the whole bird turkey is a fragile tradition, resting on a fragile supply chain with disease pressure, shrinking flocks, seasonal inefficiencies, and no premium air chilled alternative, it's time to move on and pick a better centerpiece. He, he suggests sirloin tip roast, whatever the hell that is. And he believes that the turkey growers and the plant teams, plant teams, that's the slaughterhouse workers, um, will thank you for it. Uh, that is not actually the case because there was quickly a, a response on Meating Place.
A turkey farmer's response, if you don't work in this industry, don't pretend you do. This is by John Zimmerman, who, uh, is indeed a turkey farmer and the former chair of the National Turkey Federation. So apparently he does know the industry. In spite of that, he seems to be in favor of it, which is, you know, confusing how that works. Uh, and he, he basically is saying, which I think he's trying to be charitable, that the commentary that was offered by Gregory Bloom was from someone who clearly doesn't know how any of this works.
I think he might have been he that that might have been, he was putting it as nicely as he could. He points out the Turkey production runs year round. Well, shit. That's great. Um, and the, the people in the industry, the farmers, the plant workers, don't forget the plant means slaughter in this world, veterinarians and technicians work incredibly hard to raise healthy birds and get safe, high quality, nutritious food to families. We're proud of that work. So when someone suggests we should just skip it because they personally think beef is better, that dismisses the skill and dedication of everyone who makes Thanksgiving possible.
Fuck you. I'm sorry. I'm not so supposed to curse. Um, uh. I have Thanksgiving every week, every, I have Thanksgiving every year. Uh, so do many of you. It is not people who work in turkey slaughterhouses that make it possible to give thanks, uh, and have a nice meal. But isn't this just this, this language, it's so typical, they're so in love with themselves.
Like is it self-doubt? You know, that they really know that what they're doing is evil. So they have to keep, like pretending that, that, that they work incredibly hard. Well, they probably work hard. I don't know. They're how proud they are of their work, uh, and that that they have skill and dedication and they're making Thanksgiving possible.
Uh, and, and, um, so his advice to, uh, Gregory Bloom is before declaring an entire protein obsolete, it apparently turkey is, is now no longer animals. It's just a protein. Um, walk a barn, try visiting a farm, walk a barn, talk to a grower who has been up all night checking ventilation during a heat wave. Oh my god, these are such hard jobs and they have to feed the world.
I, I made that part up. Spend time in a plant at 5:00 AM or talk to a vet dealing with an HPAI outbreak. Yeah. None of you have to do this. Like, like, don't do it. Just grow some lentils. Understand what you're criticizing before you criticize it. Well, it is fun to see them hate on each other, but it's still, oh god.
They, they make me crazy. Alright. In that same vein, there's a column in Pork Business called Live a Life That Matters. Um, and uh, this is by Jennifer Sheik. And, uh, she says, you might be surprised that one of the greatest desires people have before they die doesn't involve money, fame, or achievement, but it does require intentionality, sacrifice, and hard work.
Well, you know, I'd go along with that. I think hard work is overrated, but, but the rest of it, yeah. Um. And then they have this pic, this is very odd, they have this picture of this woman and her daughter, and they're both working in a, in a pig breeding facility, and they're holding up little tiny piglets and they're giving you big smiles, which you know is disturbing.
And this is a woman named Jennifer Romero from Hoosier Land Pork with her daughter. And then she talks about how, how she doesn't actually mention you. She was talking about what people wanna do before they die. She doesn't mention that Jennifer actually did die. I only knew that because I, I Googled her because I wanted to find out where she, what this place was, Hoosier Land.
Um, and, and, and it mentioned that she had died of cancer. It was awful. Um, but anyway, that's, that's a totally meaningless aside, um, to the article. But, uh, according to Jennifer going back to the point, she didn't, um, have the honor of knowing Jennifer. So it sounds like she might have known she was dead.
She just didn't mention it. But she was an excellent sow farm manager for Martin Family Farms and the legacy she left, 'cause, you know, s farm manager, of helping people become great in their roles on the farm and in life is far greater than she ever knew. They, they just, they're so in love with themselves and with what they do.
And they think it's so great. I, it, it always astounds me. Um, and, uh, also mentioned some Minnesota pig farmers, Dave and Tracy Mensink because they're living a life that matters by using conservation practices. Well, you wouldn't have to use conservation practices if you weren't doing something that was destructive to the environment.
Uh, from sustainability to succession planning, living a life that matters doesn't happen by chance. It requires intentionality, sacrifice, and hard work. Having a clear sense of why you do what you do, and believing your actions contribute to something larger than yourself... we're talking about pig slaughter... and lend to a life of purpose.
Your purpose is to slaughter pigs. As another new year approaches, now is the perfect time to ask yourself the hard questions that make sure you are living in alignment with your purpose. And you know what, the thing that makes me nuts and, you know, I, I do a, i, I cover a lot of these kinds of articles and kind of make fun of them because they are completely ridiculous, but they believe it.
I really think they do. They believe it. I think this is one of the fundamental problems of our time. I mean, certainly related to the politics and Trump and all of that, that that people will believe anything and they have very big, they have a lot of trouble getting the big picture.
So if they're in this like, like dreadful, dreadful situation where they're, you know, they're devoting their lives to killing pigs who don't have to be killed and having them live in misery and all of that, the whole nine yards. Within that, it, they, they don't look at the context. They just look at within that context. And, um, are they nice to their employees?
And, you know, I'm sure many of them are like, I'm sure many of them are, have, do good things in their life. But, but we have to like, take a broader view. I'm getting carried away. Let's, let's move on. Oh, another thing that's nice to know this week is that the, the entire beef industry is so mad at President Trump.
Um, this is from Ag Daily. Perspective, no shortage of emotional impacts in beef markets. This is, uh, by Brandy Buzzard, and, and she's talking about the fact, um, that, uh, you know, of course beef prices are extremely high. So I hear. That people talk about it all the time as if there's nothing else to eat. Um, and that, that as a result, uh, the president posited that we could begin... by we, I mean the United States of America could begin importing more beef from Argentina.
Uh, and the cattle ranch, the cattle ranchers are not thrilled with this as an idea because, um what... you know they're making, they're making money hand over fist at the moment, but this is how she puts it.
When a rancher markets a group of cattle, the market dictates what she'll be paid. In most years, the profit, if any, is slim. However, from 2023 to present and likely for a few more years, the prices that we are taking have been pretty great. So she does admit that they're making money hand over fist, but this whole thing of like most years, the profit, if any is slim, then why are you doing it, honey?
Like, like why you are doing this horrible thing to animals and killing them. And you, you're trying to tell us you don't make any money out of it. Uh, and you know, she goes on to talk about the obvious condescension from the president towards farmers and ranchers. Um, and how the ranchers are so disturbed that the free market is being influenced.
That one's hilarious when you think of the amount of benefit that farmers and ranchers get from the federal government, uh, which totally throws the markets off. Anyway, it's a big long article. I'm not gonna read the whole thing 'cause like who cares? But it also goes along with this other article from Meating Place, What to Do When the White House Aims at You.
This is by Janet Riley, and this is, um, this is on a different thing that they're mad at the Trump administration for, and that is the planned investigation into beef industry structure. I'm not sure either of these things are actually going to happen. You know, they're, he's always throwing things out and then they don't, you know, just, just to get, I don't know, to get attention.
An issue normally, this is, uh. An issue normally handled by the USDA, which is where they like things handled, 'cause let's face it. Um, it now saw its profile increase with the president's social media post and an inflammatory press release, claiming that quote, A handful of giant meat packers have squeezed America's cattle producers, shrunk herds, and jacked up prices at the grocery store, unquote.
And she feels that this is a hyperbolic statement that is a new tactic in an ongoing distraction strategy. What's, what are they distracting from? I think that they're talking about high prices, and I don't think high prices are a distraction. Uh, I think people are really pissed off about high prices, but maybe, uh, you could say, you could say that it's a distraction, I guess.
Um. Alright, so this, this all apparently started because everybody was getting mad at him because of the proposed Argentinian beef imports. So quote in need of a new boogeyman to shift the focus, he chose a convenient and familiar villain- meat packers.
So she's not arguing on behalf of the cattle ranchers. That was the other site. This site is more of a, uh, a big industry site and is very much on the side of the, um, of the, uh, slaughterhouses. Um, so what should an industry thrust unwillingly into controversy... I bet they're unwilling... do when facing powerful presidential narcissist? And then she goes off on like, for paragraphs on, on, on how, like what's wrong with narcissists and how he is one.
Boy, they're taking the knives out. Um, they're turning, they're turning on, on, on Trump. In this difficult period, she said, meat companies cannot permit the consumer to feel betrayed by the meat companies on which they rely for food. Yeah. God forbid that anybody should feel betrayed by the meat companies.
Uh, few people understand how the meat industry is structured and what drives prices up or down. That sure is true. They can be easily influenced by fear and misinformation. That's where meat companies need to lean into this conversation and offer genuine, sincere, personal and understandable explanations.
Yeah. Good luck with that. Do you really think that when people hear the truth, they're... As people learn more and more of the truth about the media industry, they become more sympathetic? I don't think so. Yeah. Let's open the doors.
Alright, finally, this is an interesting article. This really is. I don't know whether it means anything, but I'm gonna assume it does. This is from Hordes, which is a dairy site, a barn building plan for animal welfare. And it starts off by um, saying, which is certainly true, if tasked with envisioning the dairy barn of the future, most producers' minds would likely go straight to technological advancements. More robust robotics and perhaps more streamlined data analysis.
Well, that's the truth. That's how they think. I like the honesty that that's what they would think about. Like, you know, uh, technology, they're not thinking about cows. But then she points out, there's a recent, uh, article in the Journal of Dairy Science, which, you know, maybe you haven't read if you're not reading it regularly.
And these writers based their optimal future dairy barn on a foundation of animal welfare. Listen to this, citing the current and growing political and social climate around the issue and how these pressures intersect with economic feasibility for dairy farmers, the authors developed a concept that they hope will help support the future of dairy farming.
They are actually saying that the welfare of the animals is such a big issue that, that we have to come up with a way that dairy farmers can, can make consumers feel better about it while keeping the price of milk low. That makes me... that, that's like the best article I've seen in... I mean, the most hopeful article.
Just, just the fact that they're acknowledging that this, this really is an issue. Sometimes I think we get so frustrated that we think that nobody cares, but they're really worried. Um, and they, they, the point, the study points out that animal welfare is more than health. Yeah, that's something that they tend to, um, forget.
It has to take into account the cow's affective state and its natural tendencies. Of course, even when you're talking about dairy cows, you can't call them she or her, you have to say it. Um. And, uh, a among things that they're talking about doing is, um, cattle should be able to form a stable herd structure, exhibit species typical lying behavior.
So when they lie down, they can lie down properly, have autonomy on decisions to be indoors or outdoors. And among the practices that they're looking at is regrouping. We talked about that a couple of weeks ago. Uh, and it says, which affects establishment of stable herd structure. Like, the fact that they, they switch the cows with which they live and, um, or with whom they live.
And, and as a result, they, their relationships aren't as good. Like, who would've guessed? You suddenly have to live with a whole bunch of new cows. You don't have as close relationships with them. And, but this article is acknowledging that that actually really matters. And also early calf cow separation.
They are actually acknowledging that early calf cow separation is problematic, and that that also affects establishment of stable herd structure. Really interesting. The researchers stated farmers will have to invest more in animal friendly barns to align with consumer expectations around animal welfare.
Let's hope the consumer expectations, if they ever wake up, are a little higher than what they're talking about here. And we'll actually not be able to be met with, uh, keeping the price of milk at the ridiculously low price that it's at. And, um, it will start being, they'll start having to charge more for it, and that'll put 'em outta business.
This, that's where I'm going with this. Uh, I'm sure you are with me. That's it for this week's Rising Anxieties.
Oh. I'm supposed to remind you. Yeah. Uh, that we're still doing our fund, end of your fundraising. Please, uh, if you can, and I know some can't, but if you can think of us at this time of year, 'cause we're in a match, um, and for every dollar you donate before the end of the year, we will get two more from our very, very generous matching fund, uh, members.
It is such a great time to donate and would help us out tremendously. If you can, uh, go to ourhenhouse.org/support. Of course, you can also join the flock if you want, and we do have a great flock community. So, there are various options. That starts at $10 a month or a hundred dollars a year.
And thank you so much for tuning in this week. Don't forget to tune into The Hen Report and this week's interview.
_____________________________________________
Thank you for listening to the Our Hen House podcast! If you enjoy our podcasts, believe in our mission to effectively mainstream the movement to end the exploitation of animals, find community and solace in our shows and resources, and would like to show your support for vegan indie media, please make a donation today.
Between now and December 31, every donation up to $20,000 will be tripled! Contributions of any amount will go towards our fundraising goal and are hugely appreciated. Our Hen House is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization, so it’s tax-deductible. Thank you for helping us create quality content!
Subscribe to our show on Apple Podcasts, YouTube, or your favorite podcatcher, and don’t forget to leave a 5-star review!
Check out Our Hen House’s other podcasts: The Animal Law Podcast, The Teaching Jasmin How to Cook Vegan Podcast, and the Antiracism in Animal Advocacy Audio Series.
Follow us on social media! You can find Our Hen House on LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Threads, or Bluesky.
The Our Hen House theme song is written and performed by Michael Harren.



