Join us this week for an engaging conversation with Sarah Levy and Captain Paul Watson as they discuss their groundbreaking book, The Only Flag Worth Flying: Direct Action and The Enforcement of International Marine Conservation Law. This episode dives into the critical challenges facing marine life and how the Captain Paul Watson Foundation is stepping in to fill enforcement gaps.
This episode explores:
- The dire state of marine life due to the diminishment of phytoplankton and its implications.
- The challenges of enforcing international marine conservation laws and the role of NGOs.
- Direct action strategies by the Captain Paul Watson Foundation to combat illegal operations.
- The impact of the High Seas Treaty and its enforcement challenges.
- The role of Indigenous governance and non-state actors in marine conservation.
ABOUT OUR GUESTS

Captain Paul Watson is a Canadian-American marine conservationist and founder of the Greenpeace Foundation, Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, and Captain Paul Watson Foun/dation. A pioneer in direct-action conservation, he has led numerous campaigns to protect marine wildlife globally. His work has been featured in series like Whale Wars and documentaries such as The Cove and Watson. Author of books like Ocean Warrior, he has received honors including the Amazon Peace Prize and the Jules Verne Medal for Conservation. Time magazine recognized him as one of the 100 Environmental Heroes of the 20th Century.
Sarah Levy is a legal scholar and educator focusing on marine conservation law, integrating environmental, animal, and Indigenous rights. Her work bridges scholarship and advocacy, examining law as both an instrument of oppression and a tool of resistance for ecological and interspecies justice. Currently a PhD candidate at the Centre for Socio-Legal Studies, University of Oxford, her research explores the impacts of conflating distinct sealing practices in Canada. Sarah holds a Juris Doctor and Master of Environmental Studies from Osgoode Hall Law School and a Bachelor of Arts from Trinity College, University of Toronto. Called to the Bar of Ontario, she teaches environmental and animal law at St. Catherine’s College, Oxford, and lectures at George Brown College, Toronto.
INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT
Jasmin Singer: Welcome to the Our Hen House interview. This is Jasmin Singer.
Mariann Sullivan: This Mariann Sullivan.
Jasmin Singer: And we're so happy to welcome Sarah Levy, lawyer, scholar, and PhD candidate at the University of Oxford Center for Socio-Legal Studies and Captain Paul Watson of, of course, the Captain Paul Watson Foundation, formerly of Greenpeace and the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, and no doubt known to you all for his lifelong work on behalf of the animals of the sea, and for truly his extraordinary TV show, Whale Wars.
These two powerhouses are here to talk about their incredibly important and truly bold new book, The Only Flag Worth Flying, Direct Action and The Enforcement of International Marine Conservation Law. Welcome to Our Hen House, Sarah and Paul.
Paul Watson: Oh, thank you.
Sarah Levy: Thank you so much for having us.
Jasmin Singer: Thank you so much for being here, and before we jump in, 'cause we have so many questions for you, a quick reminder to our listeners and our viewers about the Our Hen House podcasts. Rising Anxieties comes out on Tuesdays, The Hen Report on Thursdays, and the long form interview on Fridays. Bonus for Flock members comes out on Mondays.
Don't forget that we're a podcast. We're on YouTube also, for those of you who prefer to watch your media. Please hit subscribe and like wherever you listen. Now let's go to our incredible esteemed guests today.
Sarah and Paul. The very title of your book reveals that this book is not merely reporting on what's happening.
It's taking a very strong stand on the fact that we're facing a really desperate situation and desperate measures are called for. So first of all, The Only Flag Worth Flying refers of course to the pirate flag, the Jolly Roger, and the subtitle specifically calls for direct action, challenging this idea that nation states will or even can enforce international law when it comes to the sea. So before we get to that, let's start with some facts. Can you just briefly tell us how dire the situation is? Like what is happening to marine life?
Paul Watson: Well, to me, the most difficult, uh, thing that we have to deal with is, uh, the diminishment of phytoplankton in the sea. So since 1950, there's been a 40% diminishment of all phytoplankton across the world seas. Phytoplankton provides 70% of the oxygen we breathe, sequesters enormous amounts of CO2. This is a serious problem because if phytoplankton disappears from the ocean, we die.
We do not live on this planet without phytoplankton. And why is phytoplankton being diminished? Because of the diminishment of whale populations, uh, seabirds, fish populations, marine mammals. And why that is, is because these creatures provide the nutrients that are required by phytoplankton, primarily iron, magnesium, and, and nitrogen. So diminishment of that biomass causes diminishment of the, probably the most essential group of, uh, plants on the, on the planet, which is a phytoplankton. And unfortunately, most people are unaware of that.
Mariann Sullivan: Can you go into some of the situation, uh, of, of why the way you portray things out on the ocean, which is something that I guess is obvious, but really hadn't occurred to me. It's just the wild West. Like there's no, there's kind of nobody in charge out there, right?
Paul Watson: It is the wild west. Uh, we have all the rules and the regulations, uh, to protect, uh, the, the ocean and life in the ocean, but there's a lack of enforcement. For instance, after 50 years, they finally got around last, uh, June to passing the High Seas Treaty on the protection of biodiversity beyond national jurisdictions. Great. But it's a piece of paper. It means nothing because it hasn't been enforced and nobody's enforcing it. And the, in fact, the only enforcement of any of these regulations has been by NGOs, primarily ours, uh, to go out there and directly intervene, to physically intervene. And, uh, towards doing that, I, back in the seventies, I formulated, um, a strategy which I call a aggressive non-violence, which is to aggressively intervene without causing injury and to operate within the boundaries of the law and of practicality.
And, uh, over all those years we've been very successful. Well, without being convicted of a single felony crime or losing a civil lawsuit, but uh, we have shut down hundreds of illegal operations.
Mariann Sullivan: Before we get into all of that, and that's what we really wanna talk about, I just wanna go a little bit more into this legal situation, a little bit more into what the High Seas Treaty does, but also, I mean, most people listening, myself included, really don't know anything about all of the treaties.
We just think there's things in place. Can you go a little bit more into, maybe, Sarah, you could do this like a, a really concise analysis of what the law is, how it works, and, and, uh, and, and if they were the laws that, if they were enforced as, as Paul was talking about, what would they do?
Sarah Levy: Yeah, absolutely. So when we're talking about the high seas, it's certainly not incorrect to refer to it as the Wild West in terms of the law. I'd say up until very recently with, as Paul talked about, the inception of the High Seas Treaty, but prior to that, we didn't really have any kind of major piece of legislation that was governing the high seas in terms of protecting biodiversity.
We had a few ad hoc laws and treaties. For example, the International Whaling Commission had the moratorium on whaling and certain sanctuaries and areas were protected, but of course none of those laws, even those sort of bits and pieces that we used to have, were enforced other than, you know, as Paul has basically said by the work of NGOs.
But now we have the High Seas Treaty, which is on its face, a fairly comprehensive piece of legislation that addresses this idea of the high seas being a global commons and does attempt to regulate it in some way. But it is, I think, a very ambitious piece of legislation. And what it will require is much like, you know, all of the other international treaties that we have an enforcement mechanism.
And so my wish with this of course, is that it would put in place a framework for enforcement, but what I fear is that it might actually do the opposite and perhaps create a sense of closure from people who might think, Okay, we've created the High Seas Treaty now and that's the finish line.
Because that can tend to happen sometimes with international laws where, you know, we have a group of countries or the conference of the parties getting together and there's a lot of patting on the back about, um, something being created and then not really looking at how it's put into practice.
So, you know, I'm happy to get into some of the specific articles in the High Seas Treaty because some of them do, um, provide sort of mechanisms for further NGO participation, but there's also articles in the High Seas Treaty that, um, kind of undermine the entire treaty itself. So it's, uh, yeah, it's, it's comprehensive but on the other hand side complicated, like much of international law can be so.
Jasmin Singer: And speaking of which, we do wanna hear about the specifics of that. We'll get to that in just a moment. But speaking of how complicated it is, Paul, something that has always struck me about your work is that you, you've often made this very point that you are not violating the law or making up what you think should be the law, but actually enforcing the laws that are on the books, but being ignored.
Is that about right?
Paul Watson: That's absolutely right. We're not a protest organization. We intervene against illegal activities. Uh, for example, whaling has been illegal since 1986 and, uh, you know, the Japanese and Norwegians and the Icelanders continued to do it. In 2014, we managed to get this into the, uh, International Court of Justice and they, their ruling was that Japanese was illegal, uh, yet it continued. So the problem is, is they just, uh, the countries that are involved just ignore the law. And the other problem with the High Seas Treaty is that it's been ratified by, well, the 60 countries at least, that were required to ratify it. But only, uh, France and a few other larger countries, mostly they're smaller countries.
Certainly the United States and other countries have not ratified it. And, uh, right now, you know, the United States wants to go ahead with, uh, deep seabed mining and, uh, which should be illegal, but, uh, they're just gonna do it because they don't recognize the law.
Jasmin Singer: Paul, tell us about the role of the World Charter for Nature in establishing the legal right to do what you do.
Paul Watson: I think Sarah could probably elaborate on that more, but, uh, it was passed in 19, uh, 86 by the UN General Assembly. Uh, and do you wanna elaborate on it, Sarah?
Sarah Levy: Yeah, absolutely. So the UN World Charter for Nature includes Article 21, which does actually grant, um, private actors, civil society, the ability to intervene, to protect global commons and areas that are at risk. Although the provision itself does, you know, when you read it on its face, seem to grant this authority though, the issue is that the UN World Charter for Nature is not considered binding.
So it does, um, in some way create a customary law, but this is not a treaty that many nations, you know, have ratified or considered binding. But the argument that, you know, I make in the book is that it does establish a norm for non-state actors to intervene in this way, and not only establishes it, but in some way calls for it as well.
So.
Paul Watson: And even when countries where it is binding, well, for instance, in 90, 1995, I uh, chased the Spanish drag trawlers out the grand banks of Newfoundland. I was arrested by the Canadian government charged with three counts of mischief. My defense was the UN World Charter for Nature. Well, Canada brought a law professor from Toronto that said it had no application under Canadian law.
And the judge says, but didn't Canada sign this? And she says, Yeah, but Canada signs a lot of things. So basically, uh, he advised the jury to take it into consideration and I was acquitted of the charges.
Mariann Sullivan: Yeah, I'm really sorry for laughing, but God, sometimes you just really have to, I, I think, I mean, I just wanted to take a moment to clarify for people why this book is so extraordinarily important. I mean, I was saying this to Paul before we started recording that I think this book is absolutely vital because it sounds so far that we're just talking about, we're gonna sort out what all the laws are and, and talk about a few adventures.
That's not what this book is about. This book is about how we have to change the way we look at the law of the sea, and most significantly, how it is enforced or whether it's enforced. And these are very new, very radical ideas that are, are desperately needed. And one of the things obviously that you do is challenge the assumption that only nation states have the authority to enforce laws, which is a pretty radical assumption, but it kind of begs the question of who else has the authority, I mean.
It's like, like where does that authority come from? So what are the elements that, that might provide legitimacy to a non-governmental entity, like the Paul Watson Foundation, uh, that claims to be enforcing the law and, you know, other people think they're not. And that's, that's the basically the conflict that, that I think has been the basis of Paul's work his whole life in some ways. And, and you're really trying to like, get it down onto paper, like, what's going on here? Is that right? And so where does that legitimacy come from?
Sarah Levy: The concept of legitimacy in the book is treated as sort of an outcomes based legitimacy, not legitimacy that comes through, let's say, having authority granted formally, like to a nation state. But the way that I conceive of legitimacy in looking at this issue of high seas enforcement is, who is the most effective actor?
And what I establish, um, in chapter three, especially looking at the history of international environmental law, is that nation states have been successful at creating frameworks and creating norms, but they have consistently failed to enforce them. And that there's really only one actor, which is non-state actors, and at that a very small group of those non-state actors, who have been successful at effectively enforcing these laws and doing so in a number of ways. At times actually working at the behest of the state, sometimes working alongside Interpol, but yes, sometimes working independently.
And I think the reason I came to, you know, this, this whole idea in the first place was just due to a general frustration that groups like Sea Shepherd were always being derided as vigilantes and sometimes even eco terrorists because it's so not the role that they occupy from a legal perspective when you look at the fact that there have consistently worked within the law and always actually been the ones who are upholding law against illegal actors rather than being the illegal actors themselves. Um, so yeah, it's a really interesting question. But, you know, I also take your point of, you know, what kind of door does this open for, you know, other non-state actors?
And if we're going to sort of say that, you know, certain groups are allowed to enforce laws, then, you know, where do we draw the line? And this is certainly something that might need to be negotiated at some point. But this is where, you know, I also, you know, take groups like Sea Shepherd and Captain Paul Watson Foundation as always having, you know, a high standard of accountability and not seeing that it's just a matter of being effective, but also still operating within legal norms, being accountable and, you know, as Paul mentioned very clearly having the strategy of aggressive non-violence and not tipping into that violence space as some actual eco terrorist groups have done.
But that is certainly, you know, not the category of activism in which I would place groups like Sea Shepherd and the Paul Watson Foundation. So,
Paul Watson: As an example. Um, in 1986, we sank half of Iceland's whaling fleet, destroyed their whale processing plant, shut down their operations. On the surface, that might sound quite illegal, uh, but uh, they refused to charge me. I actually, a year after this happened, I flew to Iceland to demand that I'd be arrested. And, uh, they asked me when I arrived at the airport, how long do you intend to stay? I said, I don't know, five days, five minutes, five years. You tell me. And we went to interrogation and they said, are you admitting to sinking these ships? I said, yep, and we're gonna sink the other two at the first opportunity.
But they drove me to the airport, me on a plane, told me to go home. And the minister of, uh, just Minister of Justice in Parliament that morning said, Who does he think he is? He comes into our country and demands to be arrested. Get him out of here. And the reason being is they knew, and I knew before this, that if they put me on trial in Iceland, they would be putting themselves on trial for breaking the moratorium on commercial whaling.
Jasmin Singer: Fascinating. But, so Paul, you alluded to this before, but can you define what you mean by direct action and give us some examples and explain how it differs from other types of resistance?
Paul Watson: Well, it's direct intervention really. You see an illegal activity and you go in and you, uh, interfere with your ability to carry out that illegal activity. We were able to, uh, you know, drive the Japanese fleet out of the Southern Ocean. We cost some, uh, million, I think we cost em about a hundred million dollars in total, and we saved 6,500 whales.
And that was through constant harassment, blocking their ability to whale. And, uh, we didn't hurt anybody. We, and, um, you know, there was damage, but that was primarily because they were ramming into us and causing all kinds of problems that way. But, uh, we had to be prepared for that. But I think that the, uh, in order to do this thing, you have to be prepared to take it to the next level, which is to go into the courts and hopefully set a precedent in this way. You know, and every time I've gone into, uh, the court cases, it's been difficult. And of course the wheels of the law move really slow, but we've always won. Um, you know, example, we shut down a, a tuna fishing operation in the Mediterranean off the coast of Libya. I cut the nets and I released 900 tuna that were caught illegally. And a year later my ship was arrested in Scotland and I was, uh, it was a civil case. They said that I had stolen their property. I said, but the property was this, these fish were caught illegally and the British, uh, go government or the court said, well, it doesn't matter. It's still their property. And so we had to go to trial and we won the trial, we won the case, but they had a lot of money.
So they took us to the Court of Appeals and they won at the court of appeals. And then we carried on and we went to the Supreme Court and we won. And they had to pay us a million and a half pounds in damages. So, you know, it's a long process, but uh, you know, we, by operating within the law, we can use the law to our advantage.
Mariann Sullivan: Yeah, it, it's a very high stakes business, I have to say. Alright, so the, there's three areas. I mean, getting back to what you were talking about, Sarah, like kind of creating this framework for when this works and when it doesn't. You identify these three areas where I think, uh, if I, correct me if I'm wrong: where it can be justified, where the state lacks the means to enforce it, where the state lacks the political will to enforce it, I bet we have a lot of that, um, or the state lacks jurisdiction. And then you, I mean, a, a big part of the book are these three major case studies to illustrate this work. I mean, you've told some stories, Paul, but um, and I know you can't tell us these full stories and people would have to read the book.
But you can, can you touch on these campaigns and tell us how they illustrate these, these areas where, where intervention is, uh, you can say, Well, it's appropriate here.
Sarah Levy: Yeah, absolutely. Um, so, you know, I think we can all agree and recognize that there's an enforcement vacuum, and there are so many examples of this, so many case studies that can illustrate this. But, um, as you noted, the case studies that I chose, I tried to choose a case study that was in some way illustrating a specific reason why there was an enforcement gap, and then why a non-state actor had been successful in filling it.
And so sometimes it's a matter of lacking means and lacking capacity, as you know, discussed in the example of Operation Shark Water wherein Sea Shepherd intervened on behalf of Guatemala, basically to interfere with illegal sharkfin operations that were occurring from Costa Rican vessels within their territorial waters.
And in this case, it was to some degree, a, um, yeah, lack of means, lack of resources on the part of the government to combat this. But you know, there's, there's also an element to some degree of nation states not wanting to get involved in conflict. And so then hiring groups like Sea Shepherd, you know, at the time, to get involved on their behalf.
And, you know, in, in this way, sort of the groups function as privateers rather than pirates. So that's one example. Um, but then, you know, one of the clearest examples where there's been a lack of political will to enforce the laws that we have has been with whaling in the Southern Ocean. And, um, you know, I identified that as kind of Operation Relentless, but you know, I'm sure Paul can, you know, say much more about this, but Sea Shepherd and now Captain Paul Watson Foundation have had so many operations to combat this issue over the years. But really it's been largely because there's been, although a very clear law that states that it is illegal to whale in the Southern Ocean, there's been a lack of political will on the part of nation states to go to the Southern Ocean and interfere with Japan's illegal wailing operations.
So that's, yeah, in some way, not just one case, but a very ongoing issue.
Mariann Sullivan: And that's, that's the stories that were told in Whale Wars, right? Uh, for people... when was Whale Wars? I mean, it was a while back. The older I get the,
Paul Watson: 2007 to 2016
Mariann Sullivan: Yeah, like, like if, if people, I'm sure it's still on YouTube or somewhere, so if people haven't watched it, like set aside a week or two.
Paul Watson: 1 slight correction, Sarah, is that we've never, we've never actually been hired by anybody. Uh, no countries don't hire us. We, we come to an agreement, but we have to foot the bill.
Sarah Levy: Yeah.
Paul Watson: You know,
Sarah Levy: Yeah.
Paul Watson: we
Sarah Levy: impor important distinction that the re, the resources are not provided, but just, yeah, rather the, the authority, the jurisdiction, so, yeah.
Mariann Sullivan: No, I, I'm glad you clarified that 'cause I was curious.
Paul Watson: Right now we have two campaigns going. We have a ship in the waters of French Guiana and uh, we were invited there by two very unusual groups, the government of France and, uh, the fishermen in French Guiana. Why they invited us there was because of they can't deal with the poachers that are operating in their waters. So we, we went out there with our larger vessel. We've been confiscating poaching nets every day, and we're doing that in cooperation with both the government and with the fishermen. Uh, our other campaign is set to leave next week, and that, uh, actually this Thursday, in a couple days, and that is to cross the Southern Ocean from Australia to confront the Norwegian krill fishery, which is at the southern tip of, uh, South America. This is an extremely destructive industry and it, it's actually technically legal, but last year they took 625,000 metric tons from the ocean. This year, they wanna take 1.2 million metric tons. This is the primary food for the whales, the penguins, the fishes, the seabirds, and they're really no studies as to what kind of impact that's having on the, um, on those populations.
So it's a very crucial thing and uh, really, uh, the law really hasn't had time to catch up with what they're actually doing. So our intention there is to go there and interfere with their operation. Now, hopefully, hopefully they will, um, lay charges against us, civil charges, and if they do, then that's our opportunity to get this thing challenged in the court. Now it's interesting, uh, 10 days ago I received a letter from, uh, Aker Qrill. Qrill , it's called, it's a fish, uh, a, zooplankton exploitation company. It's the most unusual letter they asked, they said, You can, we, we will give you a ship. You can come down here and come with us and we can show you the transparency of our operation. Uh, we'll give you all you need to do it. You can talk to our scientists.
And my response to that was, your scientists work for you. They're basically biostitutes, you know, they're gonna defend whatever you do no matter what. And I said, no thank you. We will go down there and see for ourselves, but we're not only gonna see for ourselves, we're gonna interfere with your activities in order to protect that marine ecosystem. So the very fact that they sent this letter indicates to me that they're quite worried that we're coming.
Mariann Sullivan: Yeah. No, it's definitely sounds like an a, a taking a chance at trying to co-opt you rather than, uh, rather than actually prove that they're doing the right thing. Is that a situ, we had mentioned that there are three areas you focused on where the state lacks the means, which you've covered, and the state lacks the political will, which, you know, I guess those kind of overlap a little bit.
Is
this where the krill are involved? Is that where the state lacks jurisdiction? I mean, who has jurisdiction over those waters, which I guess is a bigger question. Who has jurisdiction over most of the waters?
Paul Watson: There is an organization that has jurisdiction, but they pretty much rubber stamp whatever the industry wants in my my opinion.
Mariann Sullivan: Sarah, what were your examples in the book of, um, of, of a situation where the state lack, where nobody has jurisdiction, or whoever has jurisdiction is not acting?
Sarah Levy: Yeah. So in that case, um, I used Operation Ice Fish as the main case study, and that was when, um, we're talking about the illegal toothfish poachers, and that's again, an area beyond national jurisdiction. High seas, you know, there's, you know, well without of territorial waters. And that, um, resulted in the longest sea chase, um, in maritime history as far as I'm concerned, where, um, Sea Shepherd who was working basically on behalf of Interpol, was chasing The Thunder and several other, um, illegal toothfish poaching vessels.
And this was, um, actually an intervention that was very effective because it was basically over and done within 110 days, whereas Interpol had been trying to catch these vessels for around a decade. And so this was again, you know, a really good example of where Sea Shepherd as a non-state actor was so much more effective, um, than an international, a very well established international organization.
So
Paul Watson: Something, very strange about that incident is, uh, we were working with Interpol and I'm the only person in the history of Interpol to be working with them and also being on their Interpol Red Notice that they were trying to arrest me at the same time.
Jasmin Singer: That's so funny.
Does this book or this manifesto really advocate for more than the right to enforce the law that is on the books? Like what, what I'm saying is what if there isn't a law , even a toothless one? You talk about the right to non-state marine conservation, but what does that mean?
Sarah Levy: Yeah. So the scope of the book is looking at non-state actors as enforcing laws that already do exist. It's not really going beyond that because the main purpose of the book is to look at how non-state actors have filled that enforcement vacuum, not in some way taken matters of protecting our oceans into their hands.
I think that's, yeah, a really interesting topic and one that I talk about a little bit towards the conclusion and just discussing, you know, who speaks for the ocean and who is really set to be the group, the actor that is setting the standards for protecting our ocean. So I think in some way it's a bigger, um, philosophical question, but yeah, not, not really what the book, uh, deals with specifically, so.
Mariann Sullivan: I can't help but ask them these questions though. Sorry.
Sarah Levy: Yeah. Yeah, absolutely.
Mariann Sullivan: One does wonder what's next. But another thing I really wanted to ask about is the story of your recent detention. Paul, I definitely remember when this was happening. I think everybody in the movement was really nervous that this was it like, like we were going to lose you. Can you just tell that, tell folks that story?
Paul Watson: Well, you know, I've been, uh, on the Interpol Red Notice for, oh, since 2012. So the Japanese have been chasing me what, for 14 years. So, uh, unsuccessfully. I escaped from Germany the first time they had arre, had me arrested. Uh, then, uh, when, um, I was arrested in July of 24 in Greenland. Uh, it was because Denmark is killing pilot whales and dolphins, and therefore Japan teamed up with them to have me arrested. So they, it was a big deal, but I saw it as an opportunity. It was an opportunity to turn this whole thing into a campaign to focus international attention, not just on Japan's, uh, continued illegal operations, but also on the killing of pilot whales and dolphins in the Danish Faroe Islands. So, to me it was a big, uh, campaign and it was highly successful as a campaign. And, uh, so I thought it was one of our most successful campaigns, uh, overall really. Uh, and also the publicity from all of that. The backlash of all of that ended up with Interpol dismissing the in the Red Notice against me and stating very clearly that it was politically motivated, which has got, Japan is absolutely furious about. Uh, you know, this whole thing, I mean, the, the Red Notice is for war criminals and major drug traffickers and serial killers. I'm the only person in the history of Interpol to be on there for obstructing... conspiracy to obstruct business and conspiracy to trespass. Those are the charges. And Japan wants to give me 15 years in prison on that, which is ridiculous.
It's, uh, you know, it's all very politically motivated, but it has turned into, uh, a device that we can use to, uh, further embarrass the Japanese whaling industry.
Mariann Sullivan: Well, that's a positive.
Jasmin Singer: Sarah, you make the point that the work is grounded in what you call bio and ecocentric legal theory rather than an anthropocentric law and refer to the role of Indigenous governance. Can you explain what that means?
Sarah Levy: Yeah. So it's more, um, when, you know, discussing why we have international environmental laws to begin with. I sort of lay the ethical framework for that and talking about the difference between an anthropocentric ethic, which puts humans at the top, and then basically animals and nature below. It's very hierarchical in some way.
And then that there are also bio and ecocentric ethical frameworks, biocentric frameworks, which, um, value equally intrinsic value of all life. And then ecocentric ethics, which see environments and ecosystems as being all intrinsically linked and really every piece of that, whether it's an animal or a tree, as having an important and distinct role and thus having value and really looking at how those kind of ethics can be used to frame in some way and inform new approaches to law and how they have also, to a certain degree, been the basis of the creation of some of the international environmental laws that we have.
But of course, bio and ecocentric ethics are, um, nothing new in terms of many Indigenous ways of being, spiritualities, and also ways of relating and managing environments and ecosystems. And so, um, in terms of this role, not only of Indigenous ways of thinking, but also Indigenous marine governance, that's dealt with in chapter seven of the book where I go on to really talk, you know, not only about non-state actors and NGOs, but also about other groups that are really in some way replacing the role and the significance of the nation state.
And so, you know, I identify Indigenous actors as becoming very prevalent in this space. And then as well, you know, private corporations and other NGOs as stepping into that, um, gap as well. But you know, I think there's a particular role and we're seeing Indigenous groups in many different spheres that have managed and continue to manage certain marine areas in a way that's very responsible and in a way that is now in some way being, attempts to be replicated by the nation state to some degree.
And you know, we see this with the incorporation of traditional knowledge, for example, um, you know, being used almost as if it's something novel. Whereas this is, you know, biocentric and ecocentric ways of being have, um, yeah, been there for a very long time. So we're just more seeing, I think, more of an acknowledgement of that now.
Mariann Sullivan: Yeah, I think that's very exciting. And I know you just said that you don't wanna go beyond the acknowledged scope of the book, but we are sort of think, I mean, it's clear that you're thinking about where could things go. Um, even though maybe we don't know at this point. Is the, is the big challenge here, like, like we talked about vigilantism and, and how, uh, Paul's work has always been accused of that. Is, is is the big effort to draw that line between something that is organized, something that is institutional, um, to govern the oceans without going into vigilantism, but really being able to, to, uh, create a system where direct action by individuals or individual organizations is possible because nobody else is going to do it?
All right. This question has gone off the deep end. I know it doesn't make a lot of sense, but I'm trying to, like, to think about like, where is the future here? Like, or what's a possible future that we can have law, but it can also be enforced even though, you know, nation states don't seem to wanna enforce it and really frequently don't have the ability to enforce it. But it's not all just, you know, I mean, Paul is one of the people that we can trust to try to do the right thing, but I'm sure there's many, there's many pirates out there who are not the good pirates.
Paul Watson: Well, you know, a biocentric problem cannot be solved through, uh, from an anthropocentric uh, approach. And that is why after 30 climate change conferences and numerous environmental conferences, nothing has been accomplished from any of those because they're trying to solve problems through the traditional application of you know, anthropocentric values and everything. Good example, yesterday I was in a three hour meeting on trying to decide what to do with the, the, uh, orcas in Antibes in, uh, Southern France. 'Cause there's a, and they said that it's an impossible solution. And I was trying to present a solution to the Minister of Ecological Transition. And he said, Well, you know, we've only got six months now, you come to us and we've only got... I said, We were here three and a half years ago doing the same talks. We were here two years ago. We were here one years ago. And now, and you know what he did? Another meeting next month. That's all it ever is. See, politicians cannot solve problems, it's political suicide if they make...
They're afraid to make decisions. They don't have the courage, they don't have the passion, they don't even have the imagination to solve these problems. So almost everything that is being done is being done by grassroots organizations and, and very, um, and, you know, motivating individuals. And that, I mean, 'cause of Dian Fossey, we've got mountain gorillas. They didn't go extinct.
Look what Jane Goodall's done. Look at all these people that have done all of the great achievements that come from passionate, courageous, uh, um, individuals.
Mariann Sullivan: This is probably silly, but it's really reminded me of what's going on in, in so many different ways. Um, and with the news environment, like we used to rely on big institutional providers of the news, and it turned out like, you know, it didn't work and they're falling apart, but there's all of these individuals jumping up, trying to like, cover what's going on and, and tell people what's, what's happening.
And I don't really thi this, this is a problem that's similar to that in the sense that it really, really, as you point out, it really, really requires the passionate people who are not necessarily in charge of everything to be doing the work. You know? But then... this is why this book is so important, because drawing that line between allowing those people to have the role and yet not having it. And having enough of a, a structure to make sure that it's the good people jumping up and doing the work. And, and that, uh, that, that there's some structure in which these people can act is so important. I know you haven't answered all the questions, Sarah, but uh, I really appreciate how you have really started to ask them, this is important in so many different aspects of society.
Alright I, you know, I, I'm not really sure where to go from there because I do have this question that kind of goes back into the, um, into the mundane, but I'm just curious and it does have a lot to do with how much individuals or individual organizations can be effective. And that's technology. Is all of this possible now because of the growth of certain kinds of technology that make it easier for non-state actors as opposed to governments to be effective?
Sarah Levy: Yeah. And you know, that's something that's touched on in chapter seven, which you know, is really speaking in some way to what you're asking Mariann about, you know, where do we go from here? And I think that not only with, you know, the increasing prevalence of Indigenous groups and non-state actors and corporations, but also with the rise of technology as a tool that is accessible to all of these non-state actors.
It's just very much the direction that we're heading in now. That the state is becoming increasingly less relevant, um, because they are not only sometimes... they have the same capabilities, but just very often lacking the will to act. Whereas with these tools that allow non-state groups, whoever they may be, to act, they will I think very quickly and already are outpacing the nation state in many of these regards.
So it's, um, yeah, something that I think is an incredible opportunity, but also, you know, specifically from that perspective, something that I can see going off the rails if it's not of course regulated. And, um, you know, it's in some way, you know, as we see with ai, just something that is growing in many ways and evolving, um, at a rate that, you know, we cannot keep up with.
And it, that is specifically gonna be an issue of, you know, what hands does that technology fall into, and who's using it? How are they using it? But the outcome from my perspective, is going to be the same in that, you know, governments are just not really going to be the main actor, um, on this stage going forward.
So.
Jasmin Singer: Paul, you say something along the lines that in spite of what you know and what you've seen, not only have you enjoyed every moment of your adventures, but you're not pessimistic. How do you pull that off? I'm asking for a friend.
Paul Watson: Uh, many years ago I learned, uh, a very, very valuable lesson. I was a, a volunteer medic at Wounded Knee during the occupation in 1973, and we were surrounded by federal troops who were shooting at us. They wounded 46, they killed, uh, two. I went to Russell Means, who was the leader of the American Indian Movement, and I said, Look, we don't have any hope of winning here. The odds are against us. Uh, we cannot win. So what, why are we continuing?
And he told me something that stayed with me for the rest of my life and he said, Well, we're not concerned about winning or losing. We're not here, uh, because we're going to win. We're here because this is the right place to be, the right time to do it and the right thing to do.
He said, don't worry about the future. You don't have any power over the future, but you have absolute power over the present. And it's what we do in the present that will define the future. So I don't get uh, pessimistic. I don't get, uh, you know, depressed because all I can do is what I can do in the present and, uh, how the future unfolds, that's outta my control.
Mariann Sullivan: I just think that's such an important message for this moment in, uh, in, in the world and especially in the United States. And, you know, we're in such a crisis and we're all like panicked about what we can do to change it and we can't do anything to change it, it feels like. I mean, but that has always been the case with the seas and look at how much that you have accomplished. Do, do you see the story of what's going on with the oceans fit into the story of, of what people, you know, here anyway, are calling the Epstein class, this sordid story of the billionaires who want to run the world and the disempowerment?
Paul Watson: It's not that they want the, the world, they do run the world and they're manipulating it every day. They control all of the finances. I mean, that's the reason, uh, the fish are being destroyed in the ocean. That's the reason all the forests are being chopped down is nobody is, there is no media to challenge 'em. There is no, uh, there are no politicians to challenge them. The only challenge is coming from people on the ground who are sitting in trees or handcuffing themselves to bulldozers.
Sarah Levy: Yeah, and I think it's really easy to feel disempowered by all of this and succumb to a sort of nihilism. And I see that a lot with my generation. Just, you know, a sense of hopelessness, you know, climate anxiety, for example, just becoming, you know, a really paralyzing phenomenon that we're seeing. But, you know, I, I couldn't agree more, you know, with Paul's sentiment about the fact that, you know, we're acting because we, this is the right place and time to do it, and we can't be focused on whether or not it's going to solve these massive global problems.
Um, yeah, you know, it reminds me a lot of something that, uh, my, my supervisor, who, uh, was the person who really encouraged me with this master's thesis that's, you know, now taking the form of this book, had in his office. Um, you know, a few years ago he had a, a sign in his office that said, We've got to take care of the small things because the big things are all fucked up.
And I just, you know, have, have really taken that as, yeah, in some way a very kind of guiding sentiment in the same spirit as Paul's story that, you know, you have to still do what you can even if you can't fix everything.
Mariann Sullivan: Yeah, I mean it comes back to what you were saying about Russell Means, I think is sort of what else is your life about? I mean, like, like you're just gonna go along with it or, or, uh, or are you gonna fight it? And nobody has done that better than you, Paul. Actually Paul, you're kind of an inspiration 'cause you've had so much success.
I mean, I think there are a lot of people out there maybe fighting the fight who haven't pulled off as much as, uh, as you have in your life, uh, which, you know, is a tribute to, to your skills and your boldness. And, uh, and, and maybe also a little bit of luck. I don't know.
Paul Watson: All my life, uh, you know, everybody says, You're gonna get yourself killed. You're gonna get your crew killed, you know, you're totally irresponsible. I said, well, God, I'm 75 now. I'm still here. Nobody's ever died, I haven't lost a crew member and I've never injured anybody. So it, it's a, uh, aggressive non-violence is a strategy that, that works.
It's, it's successful.
Mariann Sullivan: So, uh, I'm just going to note, um, I'm also 75. Are you a child of the 1950s?
Paul Watson: I was born in 1950.
Mariann Sullivan: Me too. I always feel a unity with, with people born the same year as me. Uh, so before we, before we go, uh, we, let's get into the real world and tell us about your current work. You've, you've, you've talked about it a bit, particularly the krill campaign. Um, but tell us about the, the Captain Paul Watson Foundation, what you're doing and how people find can find out more and support it.
Paul Watson: Well, three years ago we had a hostile takeover of Sea Shepherd, you know, which I put together. Because, because of Whale Wars, it was bringing in quite a bit of money. And, uh, now we got people who I knew for 20 years who decided that I was too controversial and too confrontational, and it was a threat to the big donors. So, uh, they had dismissed me. I act, they actually offered me $300,000 a year to do nothing, say nothing, write nothing, you know, just be a figurehead. I said, I'm not gonna do that. And, uh, so they dismissed me and, uh, I had to start all over again. And, you know, God knows we have those shifts, but I also did a partnership with Sea Shepherd France, Sea Shepherd Brazil, in the UK that did not go along with those, uh, the people who took over.
So we're just carrying on the movement really. And, uh, it was my fault. I should have, I, I should not have trusted the people I did. Unfortunately, that's been one of my big weaknesses over the years, trusting people without taking the proper precautions. But anyway, uh, it also leads me to this understanding that, you know, change comes through small organizations and the bigger you get, the less successful you are. Greenpeace, the organization that I co-founded now brings in 365 million euros a year, has a staff at 3000. And I can tell you right now, we did more in the seventies with a fraction, a very small fraction of that because, so it's not the money that makes the organization, it's the passion, it's the courage, it's the imagination of the individuals who are, who are involved in it.
Mariann Sullivan: In addition to the krill campaign, can you talk about the other, uh, I, I, I guess you've alluded to a few things, but just tell us about the campaigns.
Paul Watson: Well, we have ongoing campaigns against the killing of whales and dolphins and the Faroe Islands. We're watching Iceland very closely. Uh, we're, uh, protecting turtles in Mayotte, an island between Mozambique and Madagascar. Uh. Manatees and dolphins in the Amazon trying to do a river patrol in the Xingu in Mota Grosso, uh, protecting orcas off of Iberia.
So there's numerous, numerous campaigns that we're doing and we're doing it in partnership with other organizations, not with just Sea Shepherd working with the Bob Brown Foundation in Tasmania to try and protect, uh, you know, the oceans there 'cause they're working to, they're supporting our krill campaign. So, you know, it's, you know, the strength of an ecosystem is in diversity. Therefore, the strength of a movement must be in diversity. And that means we encourage all approaches, education, litigation, legislation, activism, it all has to work together towards a I mean, 'cause none of us can do it by ourselves.
Mariann Sullivan: So Sarah, tell us about your current area. You're, you're working towards your PhD, I think, and, uh, do, do we get to ask you what, what you're writing about or is it a big secret?
Sarah Levy: No. It's no secret. Um, yeah, so my PhD project is still focusing on, you know, issues around marine mammal legislation, but turning away from international law and focusing specifically on seal hunting in Canada. I am Canadian. Yeah, I'm from, uh, Winnipeg, so from the prairies, but, um, yeah, I studied and worked in Toronto for several years.
But, um, yeah, my project, you know, concerns seal hunting, which occurs in the east coast in Canada, in the form of the commercial, um, you know, mass seal slaughter. And then also occurs in the, throughout the Arctic in Canada, um, taken on by Inuit sealers. So, um, a big part of my project is exploring the differences between these two hunting practices, because in Canada there's um, really been a very deliberate project of conflating those two practices, um, basically on the part of the Canadian government as a means of sheltering the commercial seal hunt from criticism. But then the legal aspect of my PhD is looking at the EU ban on seal products and basically, you know, that, that as a legal mechanism and also how it, in many ways, has failed to distinguish between commercial sealing and Inuit sealing, what the ramifications of that have been.
So, um, you know, in many ways the project is both an Indigenous and animal rights topic, uh, at once, so.
Mariann Sullivan: Yeah. That sounds fascinating and, and so important because, you know, obviously if, if one jurisdiction, like the EU, is willing to take a step against something that is being done because it's making people a lot of money that, uh, that that's kind of the name of the game. Um, all right, so, uh, I think that, um, I think that we should go to bonus 'cause there's a few really personal questions I wanna ask you. But um, before, before we go, I just wanna mention I'm so grateful that The Only Flag Worth Flying has been published. I think this is, I really do, I'm not just saying, I think this is a really important book, um, but it is fairly academic, uh, I know people are gonna wanna read it and, and, uh, you know, it's, it's readable but it's fairly academic.
So aside from from considering buying it, please also recommend that your library purchase it, particularly if you have any affiliation with an academic or a law library. I just think it's really important for this book to get out there and, oh, of course, at your public library as well. But, um, particularly law libraries, this should be in every law library.
So, so please do that.
Jasmin Singer: Yeah. I, I'm also just, I wanted to echo that I love, I'm super excited that this book exists and I definitely think our listeners should get yourself a, a copy or two. And, and how can people follow your work and support your efforts?
Sarah Levy: Just something about the book and its academic content versus, you know, the content that may be a little bit more interesting for the everyday reader. I just, you know, if anyone's interested in purchasing the book, just wanted to mention that chapters two and three of the book are really where the dense kind of legal framework and history is outlined. But beyond that, you know, chapters four, which really goes through the tactics that groups like Sea Shepherd have used, and then the case studies and the future of ocean governance and really looking a lot at what happened, um, in terms of Paul's detention in Greenland are, um, not as academic in nature, but um, yeah, in that regard there's kind of something for everyone throughout the book.
Mariann Sullivan: Yeah, thank you for pointing that out 'cause that's really true because actually that happened to me as I started reading it. I think guess it was chapter two, which goes into the background of international, you know, and I
Sarah Levy: Yeah,
Mariann Sullivan: lawyer, but you know, it was a little, uh,
Sarah Levy: it's very foundational. Yeah.
Mariann Sullivan: that the whole book was gonna be that dense.
And then I was like, then it got into a kind of a novel, so.
Sarah Levy: Yeah, certainly. And you know, in terms of following, um, my work, you know, you can follow that through my, um, academic website. If you search my name, you know, I come up on the Oxford website and the, um, things I'm currently working on in publications, uh, come up on their end as well, um, on LinkedIn. But, uh, yeah, I'm not, uh, not on X or, or Instagram really or anything like that.
So those are the two best ways to keep up with, uh, what's going on. So, yeah.
Jasmin Singer: And Paul, what's the best way for people? What, what link do you wanna, do you want people to connect you with since there's so many?
Paul Watson: Well, we have websites in the various social networks. Just look up the Captain Paul Watson Foundation, or Sea Shepherd France
Jasmin Singer: Okay.
Paul Watson: or whatever.
Jasmin Singer: W we'll put it all in the show notes as well. Uh, and I know you two are sticking on for a few minutes for our bonus content. So if you're listening or watching this and you're a flock member, lucky you. And if you're not yet a flock member and you feel like joining us, check it out at ourhenhouse.org/support.
It is one way that you can get access to bonus content such as the interview that we're about to do with Sarah and Paul. and thank you to those of you who already are. Thank you also for tuning in and be sure to share this episode on all your socials. We will talk to you next week.
_____________________________________________
Thank you for listening to the Our Hen House podcast! If you enjoy our podcasts, believe in our mission to effectively mainstream the movement to end the exploitation of animals, find community and solace in our shows and resources, and would like to show your support for vegan indie media, please make a donation today. Contributions of any amount are hugely appreciated. Our Hen House is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization, so it’s tax-deductible. Thank you for helping us create quality content!
Subscribe to our show on Apple Podcasts, YouTube, or your favorite podcatcher, and don’t forget to leave a 5-star review!
Check out Our Hen House’s other podcasts: The Animal Law Podcast, The Teaching Jasmin How to Cook Vegan Podcast, and the Antiracism in Animal Advocacy Audio Series.
Follow us on social media! You can find Our Hen House on LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Threads, or Bluesky.
The Our Hen House theme song is written and performed by Michael Harren.



