Our Hen House
Our Hen House
  • Home
  • Podcasts
    • Our Hen House Podcast
    • Animal Law Podcast
    • Flock Bonus Content
    • Antiracism Audio Series
    • Limited Series: Teaching Jasmin How to Cook Vegan
  • About
    • About Our Hen House
    • Inside the Coop – Bios
    • Join the Flock
    • Suggest a Guest
    • Press Coverage
    • Policies
    • Contact
  • Learn More
    • Videos
    • Blog
      • Book Reviews
    • Hen Press
    • Why Animal Rights?
      • Animal Testing and Research
      • Clothing
      • Companion Animals
      • Dairy
      • Eggs
      • Entertainment
      • Fishes
      • Meat
      • Veganism
      • Wildlife
      • What to do?
  • Donate
Blog

Which is the “Humane” Choice: Foie Gras or Faux Gras? Court Refuses to Duck the Question

by Mariann Sullivan June 28, 2013
written by Mariann Sullivan
330

ALDF_logo_150hA few weeks ago on the podcast we spoke with Carter Dillard, who heads up litigation at the Animal Legal Defense Fund, and Ella Nemcova, who runs The Regal Vegan, purveyor of the ever-delectable, and entirely plant-based, Faux Gras. They told us all about their lawsuit against Hudson Valley Foie Gras, which they claim is violating federal and California laws regarding fair business practices and false advertising by claiming that its foie gras is (be prepared to gag) the “humane choice.” They also told us all about how the judge in the case, which is currently pending in federal court in California, had refused to dismiss it after Hudson Valley claimed that The Regal Vegan had no “standing” to sue because, whatever Hudson Valley was doing, right or wrong, it wasn’t injuring The Regal Vegan. The court refused to accept that nonsensical argument — if The Regal Vegan’s Faux Gras is the only real “humane” choice, as it asserts (and, as far as we’re concerned, it obviously is), then clearly it’s being harmed when Hudson Valley tells consumers otherwise. If you missed that episode, I highly recommend giving it a listen. It’s enlightening.
While that was only a few weeks ago, there has already been another exciting development in this case that I just had to update you about.
regalvegan_logoOn the podcast, we were all talking mostly about The Regal Vegan’s right to sue. This new development, however, is about ALDF’s right to sue. In addition to trying to get The Regal Vegan thrown out of court, Hudson Valley has also been trying to have ALDF’s case dismissed as well, claiming that, regardless of what was happening to The Regal Vegan, there was certainly no possibility that ALDF was injured by anything Hudson Valley did. And it’s true that ALDF is not trying, as The Regal Vegan is, to compete with Hudson Valley.
In fact, ALDF doesn’t sell pâté‎ of any sort, humane or not (though if it did, you can bet it would be as humane as Ella’s, though possibly not as yummy since Carter is probably not as talented in the kitchen as she is). ALDF is, pure and simple, an advocacy organization, not a pâté seller.
ALDF argued, however, that it was injured. I mean, of course it was injured. Here it was, forced to spend all of its donated dollars having to fight Hudson Valley, and all because Hudson Valley was, as it asserted, breaking the law. Since ALDF’s mission is to protect animals, including ducks, it was only doing what it had to do to fulfill its mission, and that was costing it time, effort, and money. Why isn’t that just as much of an injury as that suffered by a competitor who is losing money because it is less able to sell its product?

kohl_2

Rescued foie gras ducks Kohl, Harper, and Burton at Farm Sanctuary. Photo by Jo-Anne McArthur (of We Animals), courtesy of Farm Sanctuary.


And the judge agreed. As he pointed out, “If a competitor has standing by reason of money or property spent to combat a proscribed business practice, as a competitor surely does, then why should a public interest organization not have standing for the same reason?”
While this principle has been applied in fair housing cases, this is the first time it has been applied in an animal case. If upheld and adopted in other jurisdictions, it could change the face of animal law. As OHH’s Piper Hoffman has eloquently explained, it’s currently much harder for animal law cases to get into court than any other kind of case because of the limitations of the so-called standing doctrine. If animal advocacy organizations can show that they are injured, and therefore should be allowed into court, whenever they must expend resources to fight illegal injustice, the implications would be enormous. The courts could finally become the forum they should be for deciding what the law truly requires for animals. Animals would no longer be left behind on the courtroom steps, with no way to enforce their own claims and no way for those humans who care about them to enforce claims on their behalf. In fact, this decision could go even further. As the court acknowledged, it’s not necessarily just animal advocacy organizations who are injured when they must spend their money to fight illegal cruelty. Everyone who donates to an organization in order to allow them to pursue such cases could be considered to have been injured as well.
In case you’re wondering, the judge knew he was toying with an idea that could potentially allow a wide array of litigants into court to argue that laws protecting animals were being violated. Fortunately, he didn’t let that bother him, and he didn’t let it get in the way of justice. Good for him! I for one cannot wait for the next development in this exciting case.

Share 0 FacebookTwitterPinterestEmail
previous post
Prince Edward Duck
next post
Episode 181: “Great power involves great responsibility.”

You may also like

Animal Agriculture and the Law

Got a Good Tagline?

The Best Gift Ever

Getting Over My Nerves Long Enough to Participate In My First Protest

Flock Doc: “A Spontaneous Uprising” for the Oppressed

In Recovery from Farming

Theatre: Q&A with “Dead Pile” Playwright and Director

Two Vegan Kids Teach Us About Turkeys, Equality, and Happiness

New Video Exposes Chicken Cruelty

To the Dog I Didn’t Adopt

Search Episodes

Subscribe to our Shows

Apple PodcastsGoogle PodcastsSpotifyStitcherPocketCastsAmazon Music
More
  • Apple PodcastsApple Podcasts
  • RSSRSS
  • SpotifySpotify
  • Google PodcastsGoogle Podcasts
  • Amazon MusicAmazon Music
  • StitcherStitcher
  • PocketCastsPocketCasts
  • CastBoxCastBox
  • Player.fmPlayer.fm
  • TuneInTuneIn
Apple PodcastsGoogle PodcastsSpotifyStitcherPocketCastsAmazon Music
More
  • RSSRSS
  • Apple PodcastsApple Podcasts
  • Google PodcastsGoogle Podcasts
  • SpotifySpotify
  • Amazon MusicAmazon Music
  • StitcherStitcher
  • CastBoxCastBox
  • Player.fmPlayer.fm
  • TuneInTuneIn
  • PocketCastsPocketCasts

Subscribe to OHH Emails

We don’t spam or share your email with others. Privacy policy.

Please Check Your Email to Confirm Your Subscription!

Instagram

Join us On Facebook

Join us On Facebook

Keep in touch

Facebook Twitter Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

©2023 - Our Hen House - All Rights Reserved


Back To Top
Our Hen House
  • Home
  • Podcasts
    • Our Hen House Podcast
    • Animal Law Podcast
    • Flock Bonus Content
    • Antiracism Audio Series
    • Limited Series: Teaching Jasmin How to Cook Vegan
  • About
    • About Our Hen House
    • Inside the Coop – Bios
    • Join the Flock
    • Suggest a Guest
    • Press Coverage
    • Policies
    • Contact
  • Learn More
    • Videos
    • Blog
      • Book Reviews
    • Hen Press
    • Why Animal Rights?
      • Animal Testing and Research
      • Clothing
      • Companion Animals
      • Dairy
      • Eggs
      • Entertainment
      • Fishes
      • Meat
      • Veganism
      • Wildlife
      • What to do?
  • Donate
Our Hen House
Search Podcasts
  • Home
  • Podcasts
    • Our Hen House Podcast
    • Animal Law Podcast
    • Flock Bonus Content
    • Antiracism Audio Series
    • Limited Series: Teaching Jasmin How to Cook Vegan
  • About
    • About Our Hen House
    • Inside the Coop – Bios
    • Join the Flock
    • Suggest a Guest
    • Press Coverage
    • Policies
    • Contact
  • Learn More
    • Videos
    • Blog
      • Book Reviews
    • Hen Press
    • Why Animal Rights?
      • Animal Testing and Research
      • Clothing
      • Companion Animals
      • Dairy
      • Eggs
      • Entertainment
      • Fishes
      • Meat
      • Veganism
      • Wildlife
      • What to do?
  • Donate

Subscribe

Apple PodcastsGoogle PodcastsSpotifyAmazon Music
More
  • Apple PodcastsApple Podcasts
  • RSSRSS
  • SpotifySpotify
  • Google PodcastsGoogle Podcasts
  • Amazon MusicAmazon Music
  • StitcherStitcher
  • PocketCastsPocketCasts
  • CastBoxCastBox
  • Player.fmPlayer.fm
  • TuneInTuneIn
Apple PodcastsGoogle PodcastsSpotifyAmazon Music
More
  • RSSRSS
  • Apple PodcastsApple Podcasts
  • Google PodcastsGoogle Podcasts
  • SpotifySpotify
  • Amazon MusicAmazon Music
  • StitcherStitcher
  • CastBoxCastBox
  • Player.fmPlayer.fm
  • TuneInTuneIn
  • PocketCastsPocketCasts

OHH NEWSLETTER

We don’t spam or share your email with others. Privacy policy.

Please Check Your Email to Confirm Your Subscription!

 
Sign In

Keep me signed in until I sign out

Forgot your password?

Password Recovery

A new password will be emailed to you.

Have received a new password? Login here